Comfyui inpaint only masked area reddit
Comfyui inpaint only masked area reddit. Please share your tips, tricks, and workflows for using this… It gives you a zoomable / scrollable canvas ( hold ctrl + scroll wheel / ctrl + click and drag), and the masking brush paints with left click, and erases mask with right click. I tried blend image but that was a mess. Setting the crop_factor to 1 considers only the masked area for inpainting, while increasing the crop_factor incorporates context relative to the mask for inpainting. Afterwards, with stablediffusion you inpaint the mask on the dinosaur and see if you can mess around with the output until something looks like the boy hugging the dinosaur. Not sure if they come with it or not, but they go in /models/upscale_models. The masked area will be inpainted just fine, but the rest of the image ends up having these weird subtle artifacts to them that degrades the quality of the overall images. This is more of a starter workflow which supports img2img, txt2img, a second pass sampler, between the sample passes you can preview the latent in pixelspace, mask what you want, and inpaint (it just adds mask to the latent), you can blend gradients with the loaded image, or start with an image that is only gradient. No matter what I do (feathering, mask fill, mask blur), I cannot get rid of the thin boundary between the original image and the outpainted area. I have also tried inpaint upload + controlnet reference. The outpainting illustration scenario just had a white background in its masked area, also in the base image. Sampler, Steps etc. ComfyUI also has a mask editor that can be accessed by right clicking an image in the LoadImage node and “Open in MaskEditor”. Sketch tab, actually draw the fingers manually, then mask, inpaint and hit generate. In the Impact Pack, there's a technique that involves cropping the area around the mask by a certain size, processing it, and then recompositing it. It is a tensor that helps in identifying which parts of the image need blending. Area Composition Examples. but mine do include workflows for the most part in the video description. mask_mapping_optional - If there are a variable number of masks for each image (due to use of Separate Mask Components), use the mask mapping output of that node to paste the masks into the correct image. However, if you only want to make very local modifications through Photoshop, you can apply a mask to the specific area and encode it, then blend it with the existing latent to prevent quality degradation in the rest of the image. 75 – This is the most critical parameter controlling how much the masked area will change. Fourth method. Aug 25, 2023 · Only Masked. If I check “Only Masked” it says: “ValueError: images do not match” cause I use the “Upload Mask” option. Also how do you use inpaint with only masked option to fix chars faces etc like you could do in stable diffusion. You can Load these images in ComfyUI to get the full workflow. Is this not just the standard inpainting workflow you can access here: https://comfyanonymous. 19K subscribers in the comfyui community. I've searched online but I don't see anyone having this issue so I'm hoping is some silly thing that I'm too stupid to see. A higher value mask area + blur + (padding for maskedonly) + resizing scale + (whole picture / only masked) I was trying to make sense of it all, using SD and automatic 11111 since 8 months. Depending on what you left in the "hole" before denoising it will yield differents result, if you left the original image you can use any denoise value (latent mask for inpainting in comfyui, I think its called original in a1111). This makes ComfyUI seeds reproducible across different hardware Jan 20, 2024 · (See the next section for a workflow using the inpaint model) How it works. io/ComfyUI_examples/inpaint/? In those example, the only area that's inpainted is the masked section. This approach increased the area considered exactly as much as you like without having to consider the whole image with 'inpaint whole picture'. The following images can be loaded in ComfyUI to get the full workflow. This image contain 4 different areas: night, evening, day, morning. I really like how you were able to inpaint only the masked area in a1111 in much higher resolution than the image and then resize it automatically letting me add much more detail without latent upscaling the whole image. これはInpaint areaがOnly maskedのときのみ機能します。 It works great with an inpaint mask. ) Adjust the "Grow Mask" if you want. In fact, there's a lot of inpainting stuff you can do with comfyui that you can't do with automatic1111. At least please make workflow that change masked area not very drastically We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. This is what the workflow looks like in ComfyUI: I'm utilizing the Detailer (SEGS) from the ComfyUI-Impact-Pack and am encountering a challenge in crowded scenes. I've tried to make my own workflow, by chaining a conditioning coming from controlnet and plug it into and masked conditioning, but I got bad results so far. Action Movies & Series; Animated Movies & Series; Comedy Movies & Series; Crime, Mystery, & Thriller Movies & Series; Documentary Movies & Series; Drama Movies & Series As long as Photoshop doesn't have the capability to directly edit latent variables, it's not possible. The "bounding box" is a 300px square, so the only context the model gets (assuming an 'inpaint masked' stlye workflow) is the parts at the corners of the 300px square which aren't covered by the 300px circle. This does not always cause a problem with inpaint but it can depending on the sampler selected The rest of the settings or a full screenshot would help members here guide you better. "inpaint / enhanced inpaint (img2img everywhere not masked)", toggles to invert the mask, use the masked area or full The default mask editor in Comfyui is a bit buggy for me (if I'm needing to mask the bottom edge for instance, the tool simply disappears once the edge goes over the image border, so I can't mask bottom edges. Change the senders to ID 2, attached the set latent noise mask from Receiver 1 to the input for the latent, and inpaint more if you'd like/ Doing this leaves the image in latent space, but allows you to paint a mask over the previous generation. also try it with different samplers. g. May 16, 2024 · Overview. A transparent PNG in the original size with only the newly inpainted part will be generated. From my limited knowledge, you could try to mask the hands and inpaint after (will either take longer or you'll get lucky). My conclusion: It is not predictable at all. Maybe inpaints+scetches, or inpaints with a control net for some inpaint steps. May 9, 2023 · Inpainting for the cropped area corresponding to "masked only" is already available in various custom nodes. I take the masked area (2) comfyI2I pack -> inpaint segments, run it through controlnets (3) (weaker - tile, stronger - inpainting) and then stitch the resulting area (4) comfyI2I pack -> combine and past. When using the Impact Pack's detailer, you can mask the area to inpaint and use MaskToSEGS with DetailerForEach to crop only the masked area and the surrounding area specified by crop_factor for inpainting. With the comfy I can make the flow. The area of the mask can be increased using grow_mask_by to provide the inpainting process with some additional padding to work with. It never really worked ! either i had results with 2 people appearing in this first mask area out of mask area character or i had no character at all and totally different background in this area. ive got 3 tutorials that can teach you how to set up a decent comfyui inpaint workflow. These are examples demonstrating the ConditioningSetArea node. Is there any way around this? White is the sum of maximum red, green, and blue channel values. But basically if you are doing manual inpainting make sure that the sampler producing your inpainting image is set to fixed that way it does inpainting on the same image you use for masking. Its a good idea to use the 'set latent noise mask' node instead of vae inpainting node. Absolute noob here. I can't inpaint, whenever I try to use it I just get the mask blurred out like in the picture. Inpaint only masked means the masked area gets the entire 1024 x 1024 worth of pixels and comes out super sharp, where as inpaint whole picture means it just turned my 2K picture into a 1024 x 1024 square with the I just recorded this video tutorial that explains, in just ten minutes, how to do very fast inpainting only on masked areas in ComfyUI. I have tried using inpaint upload + controlnet inpaint, it was just simply putting the new texture onto the mask without keeping the original geometry. In most cases I am satisfied with the result Hi folks, This is a follow up to the nodes I published a few days ago. You do a manual mask via Mask Editor, then it will feed into a ksampler and inpaint the masked area. Inpaint whole picture. Welcome to the unofficial ComfyUI subreddit. If Convert Image to Mask is working correctly then the mask should be correct for this. I have had my suspicions that some of the mask generating nodes might not be generating valid masks but the convert mask to image node is liberal enough to accept masks that other nodes might not. In addition to a whole image inpainting and mask only inpainting, I also have workflows that upscale the masked region to do an inpaint and then downscale it back to the original resolution when pasting it back in. I switched to Comfy completely some time ago and while I love how quick and flexible it is, I can't really deal with inpainting. What does not make sense to me especially is the repetition of faces in the masked area in some combinations. It enables forcing a specific resolution (e. When inpainting, you can raise the resolution higher than the original image, and the results are more detailed. 1024x1024 for SDXL models). In my inpaint workflow I do some manipulation of the initial image (add noise, then use blurs mask to re-paste original overtop the area I do not intend to change), and it generally yields better inpainting around the seams (#2 step below), I also noted some of the other nodes I use as well. I took a picture, generated a mask and then inpaint the masked area using a picture of black marble texture. Also if you want better quality inpaint I would recommend the impactpack SEGSdetailer node. Just take the cropped part from mask and literally just superimpose it. Residency. Jun 19, 2024 · mask. With simple setups the VAE Encode/Decode steps will cause changes to the unmasked portions of the Inpaint frame, and I really hated that so this workflow gets around that issue. The mask ensures that only the inpainted areas are modified, leaving the rest of the image untouched. I only get image with mask as output. Another trick I haven't seen mentioned, that I personally use. However this does not allow existing content in the masked area, denoise strength must be 1. The problem I have is that the mask seems to "stick" after the first inpaint. I'm using the 1. I'm trying to use face detailer and it asks me to connect something to 'force inpaint' and it doesn't render. Layer copy & paste this PNG on top of the original in your go to image editing software. (custom node) Fooocus inpaint can be used with ComfyUI's VAE Encode (for Inpainting) directly. not only does Inpaint whole picture look like crap, it's resizing my entire picture too. 0 hey hey, so the main issue may be the prompt you are sending the sampler, your prompt is only applying to the masked area. I'm looking for a way to do a "Only masked" Inpainting like in Auto1111 in order to retouch skin on some "real" pictures while preserving quality. Doing the equivalent of Inpaint Masked Area Only was far more challenging. Please keep posted images SFW. 4. seen a lot of people asking for something similar, it can be refined but works great for quickly changing the image to run back through an ipadapter or something similar, always thought you had to use 'vae encode for inpainting' , turns out you just vae encode and set a latent noise mask, i usually just leave inpaint controlnet between 0. Link: Tutorial: Inpainting only on masked area in ComfyUI. This tutorial presents novel nodes and a workflow that allow fast seamless inpainting, outpainting, and inpainting only on a masked area in ComfyUI, similar Aug 5, 2023 · While 'Set Latent Noise Mask' updates only the masked area, it takes a long time to process large images because it considers the entire image area. Might get lucky with this. With Masquerades nodes (install using comfyui node manager), you can maskToregion, cropByregion (both the image and the large mask), inpaint the smaller image, pasteByMask into the smaller image, then pasteByRegion into the bigger image. Whole picture takes the entire picture into account. The tool attempts to detail every face, which significantly slows down the process and compromises the quality of the results. com/watch?v=mI0UWm7BNtQ. It will detect the resolution of the masked area, and crop out an area that is [Masked Pixels]*Crop factor. The main advantages these nodes offer are: They make it much faster to inpaint than when sampling the whole image. try putting like 'legs, armored' or somthing similar and running it at 0. Only Masked crops a small area around the selected area that is looked and, changed, and then placed back into the larger picture. I usually keep it between 1. Inpaint only masked. 5 Inpaint model (realisticVision one) using VAE Encore (for Inpainting) : It work much much better ! I got 1 character. Turn steps down to 10, masked only, lowish resolution, batch of 15 images. 95) 2) SD1. Mask spot on background where subject is placed, then use ipadapter to inpaint subject: I found that regenerating the subject from scratch is challenging and many details are los. Check the updated (5--minute-long) tutorial here: https://www. Imagine you have a 1000px image with a circular mask that's about 300px. I recently published a couple of nodes that automate and significantly improve inpainting by enabling the sampling to take place only on the masked area. ) This makes the image larger but also makes the inpainting more detailed. 5-2, so the model can see what's around your inpainting area and correct for it. A crop factor of 1 results in Hi, is there an analogous workflow/custom nodes for WebUI's "Masked Only" inpainting option in ComfyUI? I am trying to experiment with Animatediff + inpainting but inpainting in ComfyUI always generates on a subset of pixels on my original image so the inpainted region always ends up low quality. Has anyone encountered this problem before? If so, I would greatly appreciate any advice on how to fix it. This essentially acts like the "Padding Pixels" function in Automatic1111. Anyway, How to inpaint at full resolution? Cause I often inpaint outpainted images that have different resolutions from 512x512 Welcome to the unofficial ComfyUI subreddit. Generate. I already tried it and this doesnt seems to work. 0 it will crop right to the mask. yeah ps will work fine, just cut out the image to transparent where you want to inpaint and load it as a separate image as mask. Get something to drink. 🛟 Support Hold left-click to create a mask over the area you want to change, it's good to create a mask that's slightly bigger than what you need. This mode treats the masked area as the only reference point during the inpainting process. Using the Automatic1111 interface, you have two options for inpainting, "Whole Picture" or "Only Masked". This sounds similar to the option "Inpaint at full resolution, padding pixels" found in A1111 inpainting tabs, when you are applying a denoising only to a masked area. Hey, I need help with masking and inpainting in comfyui, I’m relatively new to it. 7 using set latent noise mask. Or you could use a photoeditor like GIMP (free), photoshop, photopea and make a rough fix of the fingers and then do an Img2Img in comfyui at low denoise (0. Main thing is if pixel padding is set too low then it doesn't have much context of what's around the masked area and you can end up with results that don't blend with the rest of the image. ) edit: I'm referring to the 'inpaint only masked' option in a1111. The "Inpaint Segments" node in the Comfy I2I node pack was key to the solution for me (this has the inpaint frame size and padding and such). Any other ideas? I figured this should be easy. Your prompts will now work on the mask rather than the image itself, allowing you to fix the hand with a larger area to work with. Leave this unused otherwise. Batch size: 4 – How many inpainting images to generate each time. Learn how to master inpainting on large images using ComfyUI and Stable Diffusion. It took me hours to get one I'm more or less happy with, where I feather the mask ( feather nodes usually don't work how I want to, so I use mask2image, blur the image, then image2mask ), 'only masked area' where it also apply to the controlnet ( applying it to the controlnet was probably the worst part ), and If I inpaint mask and then invert … it avoids that area … but the pesky vaedecode wrecks the details of the masked area. (Due to mask blur these small masks won't actually be modified, they just expand the bounding box of the inpainting. If you use whole picture, this will change only the masked part while considering the rest of the image as a reference, while if you click on “Only Masked” only that part of the image will be recreated, only the part you masked will be referenced. And for every area I need to replace promt, mask, controlnet, make a try, if something going wrong make step back (and replace all back), and, if my idea is relatively complex, it will really become annoying process. Do not worry about how terrible that photoshop looks. Inpainting is perfect for this. A somewhat decent inpainting workflow in comfyui can be a pain in the ass to make. It enables downscaling before sampling if the area is too large, in order to avoid artifacts such as double heads or double bodies. The Inpaint Crop and Stitch nodes can be downloaded using ComfyUI-Manager, just look for "Inpaint-CropAndStitch". OpenOutpaint also has layers so you can toggle different edits on different layers if you need to. 5 Whereas in A1111, I remember the controlnet inpaint_only+lama only focus on the outpainted area (the black box) while using the original image as a reference. (Copy paste layer on top). Use the VAEEncodeForInpainting node, give it the image you want to inpaint and the mask, then pass the latent it produces to a KSampler node to inpaint just the masked area. So it uses less resource. May 17, 2023 · In Stable Diffusion, “Inpaint Area” changes which part of the image is inpainted. The area you inpaint gets rendered in the same resolution as your starting image. In fact, it works better than the traditional approach. When finished, press 'Save to Node'. " For "only masked," using the Impact Pack's detailer simplifies the process. youtube. . Save the new image. 0. Feel like theres prob an easier way but this is all I could figure out. Impact packs detailer is pretty good. You only need the dinosaur to be in the right spot. I am training controlnet to complete the combination of Inpainting and other control methods, but I am not quite clear about the general process of inpainting, and the result I generate always cannot be perfectly restored to the area without mask. 6), and then you can run it through another sampler if you want to try and get more detailer. If inpaint regenerates the entire boxed area near the mask, instead of just the mask, then pasting the old image over the new one means that the inpainted region won't mesh well with the old image--there will be a layer of disconnect. Uh, your seed is set to random on the first sampler. The image that I'm using was previously generated by inpaint but it's not connected to anything anymore. ) Its not that easy, inpaint CN works on comfy but the lama preprocessor actually fill the outpaint area with the lama model (which is already some kind of inpainting) instead of starting with a blank image. Aug 22, 2023 · デフォルト値だと違和感が出てしまう可能性があるため、Only maskedを使用する際は注意が必要です。 Whole picture Only masked ・ Only masked padding, pixels. vae inpainting needs to be run at 1. i think, its hard to tell what you think is wrong. does not reproduce A1111 behavior of inpaint only area (it seems somehow zoom-in it before render) or whole picture nor amount of influence. (I think I haven't used A1111 in a while. Meaning you can have subtle changes in the masked area. This is because the Empty Latent Image noise on ComfyUI is generated on the CPU while the a1111 UI generates it on the GPU. It's not necessary, but can be useful. 0 denoising, but set latent denoising can use the original background image because it just masks with noise instead of empty latent. Only masked is mostly used as a fast method to greatly increase the quality of a select area provided that the size of inpaint mask is considerably smaller than image resolution specified in the img2img settings. I want to create a workflow which takes an image of a person and generate a new person’s face and body in the exact same clothes and pose. If your starting image is 1024x1024, the image gets resized so that the inpainted area becomes the same size as the starting image which is 1024x1024. (cfg 8, den 0. Please share your tips, tricks, and workflows for using this software to create your AI art. So for example, if I have a 512x768 image, with a full body and smaller / zoomed out face, I inpaint the face, but change the res to 1024x1536, and it gives better detail and definition to the area I am Posted in r/comfyui by u/thebestplanetispluto • 2 points and 31 comments Load the upscaled image to the workflow, use ComfyShop to draw a mask and inpaint. But, I'm also looking for some help figuring out how to mask the area just around the subject, as I think that'll have the best results. It will be centered on the masked area and may extend outside the masked area. Remove all from prompt except "female hand" and activate all of my negative "bad hands" embeddings. The trick is NOT to use the VAE Encode (Inpaint) node (which is meant to be used with an inpainting model), but: Encode the pixel images with the VAE Encode node. This was not an issue with WebUI where I can say, inpaint a cert The Inpaint Model Conditioning node will leave the original content in the masked area. Oct 26, 2023 · 3. 3-0. This comprehensive tutorial covers 10 vital steps, including cropping, mask detection, sampler erasure, mask fine-tuning, and streamlined inpainting for incredible results. I know that the most direct way is to directly cover it with the original image. The "crop factor" setting controls the area aroung the mask that will be cropped - so at 1. ) Adjust "Crop Factor" on the "Mask to SEGS" node. I added the settings, but I've tried every combination and the result is the same. Simply save and then drag and drop relevant image into your ComfyUI interface window with or without ControlNet Inpaint model installed, load png image with or without mask you want to edit, modify some prompts, edit mask (if necessary), press "Queue Prompt" and wait for the AI generation to complete. I managed to handle the whole selection and masking process, but it looks like it doesn't do the "Only mask" Inpainting at a given resolution, but more like the equivalent of a masked Inpainting at 3. If you set guide_size to a low value and force_inpaint to true, inpainting is done at the original size. Use the Set Latent Noise Mask to attach the inpaint mask to the latent sample. LAMA: as far as I know that does a kind of rough "pre-inpaint" on the image and then uses it as base (like in img2img) - so it would be a bit different than the existing pre-processors in Comfy, which only act as input to ControlNet. I think you need an extra step to somehow mask the black box area so controlnet only focus the mask instead of the entire picture. 5-1. Denoising strength: 0. Nov 28, 2023 · The default settings are pretty good. You only need to confirm a few things: Inpaint area: Only masked – We want to regenerate the masked area. The only thing that kind of work was sequencing several inpaintings, starting from generating a background, then inpaint each character in a specific region defined by a mask. The main advantages of inpainting only in a masked area with these nodes are: It's much faster than sampling the whole image. You can generate the mask by right-clicking on the load image and manually adding your mask. For example, in the Impact Pack, there is a feature that cuts out a specific masked area based on the crop_factor and inpaints it in the form of a "detailer. I just recorded this video tutorial that explains, in just ten minutes, how to do very fast inpainting only on masked areas in ComfyUI. I'm trying to build a workflow where I inpaint a part of the image, and then AFTER the inpaint I do another img2img pass on the whole image. The mask parameter is used to specify the regions of the original image that have been inpainted. suuuuup, :Dso, with set latent noise mask, it is trying to turn that blue/white sky into a space ship, this may not be enough for it, a higher denoise value is more likely to work in this instance, also if you want to creatively inpaint then inpainting models are not as good as they want to use what exists to make an image more than a normal model. Area composition with Anything-V3 + second pass with AbyssOrangeMix2_hard. I tried experimenting with adding latent noise to masked area, mix with source latent by mask, itc, but cant do anything good. The lama model is known to be less creative (ie trying to fill without adding random new objets) which is why it is found to be better. A crop factor of 1 results in Yes, only the masked part is denoised. Inpainting a cat with the v2 inpainting model: Inpainting a woman with the v2 inpainting model: It also works with non inpainting models. However, I'm having a really hard time with outpainting scenarios. its the kind of thing thats a bit fiddly to use so using someone elses workflow might be of limited use to you. Aug 5, 2023 · While 'Set Latent Noise Mask' updates only the masked area, it takes a long time to process large images because it considers the entire image area. Since then, I've implemented several feature requests (thanks for raising … Yeah pixel padding is only relevant when you inpaint Masked Only but it can have a big impact on results. Globally he said that : " inpaint_only is a simple inpaint preprocessor that allows you to inpaint without changing unmasked areas (even in txt2img)" and that " inpaint_only never change unmasked areas (even in t2i) but inpaint_global_harmonious will change unmasked areas (without the help of a1111's i2i inpaint) If you use a1111's i2i inpaint Because the prompt is plural eyes not eye, the mask is on 1 eye from your screen capture. github. Outline Mask: Unfortunately, it doesn't work well because apparently you can't just inpaint a mask; by default, you also end up painting the area around it, so the subject still loses detail IPAdapter: If you have to regenerate the subject or the background from scratch, it invariably loses too much likeness Still experimenting with it though. comfy uis inpainting and masking aint perfect. Not really what i expected. Easy to do in photoshop. The masked area leaves a sort of "shadow" on the generated picture where it appears that the area has increased opacity. This parameter is essential for precise and controlled Aug 19, 2023 · How to reproduce the same image from a1111 in ComfyUI? You can’t reproduce the same image in a pixel-perfect fashion, you can only get similar images. [6]. Note that if force_inpaint is turned off, inpainting might not occur due to the guide_size. oqapyphi lgliwy izumu wdxfw vgxbup vjzb fxgmalk vrreif kce kav